| 11.03.26 19:00 | Sutton United - : - Southampton U21 |
| 03.29.27 14:00 | Sutton United - : - Yeovil Town |
| 04.03.27 14:00 | Sutton United - : - Worthing |
| 04.10.27 14:00 | Solihull Moors - : - Sutton United |
| 04.17.27 14:00 | AFC Fylde - : - Sutton United |
| 04.24.27 11:30 | Sutton United - : - Carlisle United |
| 10.31.26 15:00 | Worthing 0 : 3 Sutton United |
| 10.28.26 19:45 | Sutton United 2 : 0 Aldershot Town |
| 10.24.26 11:30 | Harrogate Town 3 : 1 Sutton United |
| 10.17.26 14:00 | Sutton United 1 : 0 Truro City FC |
| 10.13.26 18:00 | Sutton United 3 : 2 West Bromwich U21 |
| 10.09.26 18:45 | Sutton United 0 : 2 Boreham Wood |
| 10.03.26 14:00 | Kidderminster Harriers 1 : 1 Sutton United |
| 09.30.26 18:45 | Tamworth 2 : 0 Sutton United |
| 09.26.26 14:00 | Sutton United 3 : 3 Forest Green Rovers |
| 09.19.26 14:00 | Halifax Town 1 : 1 Sutton United |
| 09.15.26 18:45 | Sutton United 2 : 1 Eastleigh |
| 09.12.26 14:00 | Sutton United 0 : 2 Scunthorpe United |
| 09.08.26 18:00 | Sutton United 6 : 7 Birmingham U21 |
| 09.05.26 14:00 | Barrow 3 : 0 Sutton United |
| 08.31.26 14:00 | Sutton United 0 : 2 Wealdstone |
| 08.28.26 18:45 | Gateshead FC 0 : 1 Sutton United |
| 08.22.26 11:30 | Sutton United 2 : 1 Hartlepool United |
| 08.15.26 14:00 | Sutton United 1 : 0 Altrincham |
| 08.08.26 14:00 | Woking 0 : 3 Sutton United |
Clubs | P | Pts |
1 | Sutton United | 16 | 24 |